United Kingdom

Document	Status	Date received or posted by the secretariat
Datasheet ACCC/C/2008/23		21.10.2010
Determination on admissibility	At CC-19	07.03.2008
Communication		21.02.2008
Summary Note	Summary of the communication provided by the communicant	21.02.2008
Briefing Note for the Court of Appeal	Addendum 1 to the communication	21.02.2008
Judgement of High Court of 9 November 2007	Addendum 2 to the communication	21.02.2008
Judgement of High Court of 21 December 2007	Addendum 3 to the communication	21.02.2008
Order of 21 December 2007	Addendum 4 to the communication	21.02.2008
Letter to the Party informing about the communication and raising several points	Letter from the secretariat sent at the request of the Committee made at CC-19	17.04.2008
Letter to the communicant regarding preliminary admissibility of the communication and request for additional information	Letter from the secretariat sent at the request of the Committee made at CC-19	17.04.2008
Letter from the Party concerned regarding delay in providing response dated 7.07.2008	Letter to the secretariat	02.08.2008
Letter from the Party concerned regarding delay in providing response dated 6.08.2008	Letter to the secretariat	06.08.2008
Letter from the Party concerned regarding delay in providing response dated 1.09.2008	Letter to the secretariat	01.09.2008
Letter to the Party concerned conveying Committee's considerations with regard to extension of time for the Party's response	Letter from the secretariat on behalf of the Committee	25.09.2008
Letter from the communicant concerning the delay in the provision of the response byt he Party concerned and providing additional information	Letter to the secretariat	29.09.2008
Warning letter from the Environmental Agency to Hinton Organics dated 14.02.2008	Appendix 1 to the additional information from the communicant	29.09.2008
Summayr history of regulation of Hilton Organics (Environment Agency)	Appendix 2 to the additional information from the communicant	29.09.2008
South Gloucestershire in-vessel composter: chronological sequence of preferred locations	Appendix 3 to the additional information from the communicant	29.09.2008
Initial response provided by the Party (as amended on 22 May 2009) addressing the questions posed in the penultimate paragraph of the letter from the Secretariat on behalf of the Committee dated 17 April 2008	Response made pursuant to para. 23 of the annex to decision I/7 and in connection with the requests of the Committee made at CC-19 and CC-21	22.05.2009
Letter from the Communicant	Letter to the Committeeaddressing the Party's response and forwarding the additional information	11.11.2008
Letter of 15.01.2008 from the Environmental Sevices of BANES concerning the communicant's complaint	Additional information from the communicant	11.11.2008
Summary of complaints dated 19.05.2008	Additional information from the communicant	11.11.2008
Letter of complaint from the communicant to the BANES Council (11.11.2008)	Additional information from the communicant	11.11.2008
Letter of complaint from the communicant to the Environmental Agency (11.11.2008)	Additional information from the communicant	11.11.2008
Letter to the Party concerned conveying the Committee's considerations wtih regard to extension of time for the Party's reponse and the timing of the discussion on the subject matter of the communication	Letter from the secretariat on behalf of the Committee	12.01.2009
Letter to the communicant conveying the Committee's considerations wtih regard to extension of time for the Party's reponse and the timing of the discussion on the subject matter of the communication	Letter from the secretariat on behalf of the Committee	12.01.2009
Letter from the communicant in response to the Committee's letter on 12.01.2009	Letter from the communicant received by the secretariat	24.03.2009
Warning letter from the Environment Agency to Defendant dating 14.02.2009	Addendum 1 to the letter	24.03.2009
Judgement of the Court of Appeal	Addendum 2 to the letter	24.03.2009
Letter from the Party concerned with regard to further information on compliance by the United Kingdom with the provisions of the Convention	Letter from the Party concerned received by the secretariat	26.03.2009
Letter from the communicant requesting the Committee to proceed with consideration of the communication	Letter from the communicant received by the secretariat	30.03.2009
Letter to the communicant regarding the discussion on the subject matter of the communication	Letter from the secretariat on behalf of the Committee	15.04.2009
Letter to the Party concerned regarding the discussion on the subject matter of the communication	Letter from the secretariat on behalf of the Committee	15.04.2009
Letter from the Party concerned requesting delay in the discussion of the case in order to have three communications concerning the UK discussed during the same meeting	Letter from the Party concerned	12.05.2009
Letter from the communicant requesting not to postpone the discussion	Letter from the communicant	14.05.2009
Amicus Brief document for communications 23, 27 and 33 received by CAJE	Proposal by CAJE to the Secretariat	22.05.2009
Annex A - Rule 44.3, Civil Procedure Rules	Annex to the Amicus Brief	28.05.2009
Annex B - Using the Law: Barriers and Opportunities for Environmental Justice (Capacity Global)	Annex to the Amicus Brief	28.05.2009
Annex C - Environmental Justice (the Environmental Justice Project)	Annex to the Amicus Brief	28.05.2009
Annex D - Civil Law Aspects of Environmental Justice (ELF)	Annex to the Amicus Brief	28.05.2009
Annex E - Modernising Environmental Justice (UCL)	Annex to the Amicus Brief	28.05.2009
Annex F - CAJE Briefing - Access to Justice: Making it Affordable	Annex to the Amicus Brief	28.05.2009
Annex G - UKELA Position Statement on Costs	Annex to the Amicus Brief	28.05.2009
Annex H - Access to Justice in Environmental Matters (Professor Nicolas de Sadeleer)	Annex to the Amicus Brief	28.05.2009
Annex I - Litigating the Public Interest (Liberty/Civil Liberties Trust)	Annex to the Amicus Brief	28.05.2009
Annex J - Measures on Access to Justice in Environmental Matters (Milieu Ltd Report, UK)	Annex to the Amicus Brief	28.05.2009
Annex K - Judgment in R v. (Francis Morgan) v Hinton Organics (Wessex Ltd.)	Annex to the Amicus Brief	28.05.2009
Annex L - CAJE letters to the Civil Procedure Rules Committee (Letter dated 10th June 2005 to CPRC) (Letter dated 23 July 2008 to CPRC, Enclosure to 23 July 2008 letter)	Annex to the Amicus Brief	28.05.2009
Annex M - Table showing JRs embarked upon by selected CAJE members since 1990	Annex to the Amicus Brief	28.05.2009
Annex N - Ensuring Access to Justice in England and Wales (Sullivan Report)	Annex to the Amicus Brief	28.05.2009
Annex O - Review of Civil Litigation Costs (Jackson Preliminary Report)	Annex to the Amicus Brief	28.05.2009
Annex P - CAJE complaint to the European Commission	Annex to the Amicus Brief	28.05.2009
Annex Q - Chambers	Annex to the Amicus Brief	28.05.2009
Annex R - Judgment in Corner House	Annex to the Amicus Brief	28.05.2009
Letter to the parties concerned of communications 23, 27 and 33 with regard to decisions for discussion plans of these three communications	Letter from the secretariat	27.05.2009
Letter from the Party concerned communicating its position for the hearing on 1 July 2009	Letter from the Party concerned	23.06.2009
Annex - Documents supporting Party concerned's position	Letter from the Party concerned	23.06.2009
Letter from the communicant communicating its position for the hearing on 1 July 2009	Letter from the communicant	23.06.2009
Annex - Documents supporting communicant's position	Annex to the letter	23.06.2009
Letter from the communicant outlining certain cost-related aspects	Letter from the communicant	30.06.2009
Letter responding to the points raised at CC-24 (text) (disclaimer)	From the Party concerned	22.07.2009
Annex 1 - Agreed statement between communicant and Party concerned	Annex to the letter	22.07.2009
Communicant post-meeting letter responding to the points raised at CC-24	Letter from the communicant	23.07.2009
European Court of Justice in Case C-427/07, Commission v Ireland (cover) (decision)	From CAJE	27.07.2009
Letter from the Party concerned with issues on C23 and C33	Letter from the Party concerned	30.07.2009
Message with reply concerning costs of the Environment Agency and BANES	Message from the communicant	21.09.2009
Annex 1 - Claimants’ skeleton argument in support of permission to appeal and substantive appeal if permission granted	Annex to message from the communicant	21.09.2009
Annex 2 - Matter related to BANES	Annex to message from the communicant	21.09.2009
Annex 3 - Matter related to the Environment Agency	Annex to message from the communicant	21.09.2009
Annex 4 - Skeleton argument of the appellants	Annex to message from the communicant	21.09.2009
Draft statement concerning the allegation of a conflict of interest	Prepared by the Compliance Committee	24.09.2009
Message containing reaction from the Party concerned with regard to the conflict of interest issue	Letter from the Party concerned	25.09.2009
Statement concerning the allegation of a conflict of interest	Prepared by the Compliance Committee	25.09.2009
Statement with regard to the conflict of interest issue	Letter from CAJE	30.09.2009
Message from the communicant containing reaction from the communicant with regard to the conflict of interest issue	Letter from the communicant	05.10.2009
Message to all parties concerned (including the amicus) with regard to the outcome after CC-25 and the following steps concerning the case	Letter from the secretariat	13.11.2009
Message to the parties concerned with a further point to clarify about the costs involved	Letter from the secretariat	08.01.2010
Letter to the Committee replying to the clarification about the costs involved	Letter from the communicant	08.01.2010
Annex - Documentation mentioned in the reply letter	Annex to the letter from the communicant	08.01.2010
Letter to the Committee replying to the clarification about the costs involved	Letter from the Party concerned	11.01.2010
Letter in reply to the previous message from the Party concerned (Cover) (Annex)	Letter from the communicant	16.01.2010
Message updating the Compliance Committee on the publication of Lord Justice Jackson's Report on Civil Litigation Costs on 14th January 2010	Letter from CAJE	20.01.2010
Letter posing questions to the parties concerned	Letter from the secretariat	09.03.2010
Reply from the Party concerned to the letter from the secretariat dated 9 March 2010	Message from the Party concerned	12.03.2010
Reply from the communicant to the letter from the secretariat dated 9 March 2010	Message from the communicant	12.03.2010
Comments on the Jackson Report	Message from the communicant	12.03.2010
Letter on the cost issue with regard to C23, C27 and C33	Message from CAJE	17.03.2010
Letter from the communicant with further documentation requested - Cover	Letter from the communicant	12.04.2010
Annex 1 - Communicant's note of 10 April 2010	Letter from the communicant	12.04.2010
Annex 2 - Annex 1 to communicant's note of 10 April 2010	Letter from the communicant	12.04.2010
Annex 1 - Annex 2 to communicant's note of 10 April 2010	Letter from the communicant	12.04.2010
Letter from the Party concerned with further documentation requested - Cover	Letter from the Party concerned	13.04.2010
Annex 1 - Judgement of 9 November 2009	Letter from the Party concerned	13.04.2010
Message from Environmental Law Foundation on the three UK cases	Message from Environmental Law Foundation	20.05.2010
Annex - Report on the three UK cases	Annex to the message from Environmental Law Foundation	20.05.2010
Letter from CAJE about the three UK cases (C23, C27, C33)	Message from CAJE	26.05.2010
Annex 1 - Letter about the Pallikaropoulos case	Annex to the message from CAJE	26.05.2010
Annex 2 - Final judgement of the Pallikaropoulos v SSEFRA case	Annex to the message from CAJE	26.05.2010
Letter sending the draft findings to the parties concerned	Letter from the secretariat	07.06.2010
Draft findings	Letter from the secretariat	07.06.2010
Comments on the draft findings	Letter from the communincant	11.06.2010
Comments on the draft findings	Letter from the Party concerned	18.06.2010
Further comments on the draft findings	Letter from the communicant	22.06.2010
Findings and letters from the secretariat to the Party concerned and to the communicant	From the secretariat	18.10.2010
Follow-up on compliance	From the secretariat	07.01.2011
Findings (En Fr Ru)	From the secretariat	08.02.2011
Response on follow-up	From the Party concerned	15.02.2011
Response by CAJE to the UK response	From CAJE	25.02.2011
Response by Lord Justice Sullivan's Working Group on Access to Environmental Justice to all three consultation papers of the Ministry of Justice	From CAJE	25.02.2011
Response by CAJE to MoJ consultation papers	From CAJE	25.02.2011
Response by CAJE MoJ on injunctions	From CAJE	25.02.2011
Draft report from the Committee and cover letter	From the secretariat	01.03.2011
Response from CAJE (email)	From CAJE	14.03.2011
Response from the Party	From the Party concerned	15.03.2011
Report of the Committee	From the secretariat	19.05.2011