• English

ACCC/C/2014/100 United Kingdom

DocumentStatus  Date received or
posted by the secretariat
Preliminary determination of admissibility

Covering letter
Communication
Index of annexes
Annex 1
Annex 2
Annex 3
Annex 4
Annex 5
Annex 6
Annex 7
Annex 8
Annex 9
Annex 10

From the communicant15.04.2014
Letter forwarding communication to the Party concernedFrom the secretariat09.09.2014
Letter to communicantFrom the secretariat09.09.2014

Covering letter 
Annex A Party concerned's response to communication
Annex B List of annexes

Additional annexes

Annex 1  Command Paper High Speed Rail Investing in Britain's Future - Decisions and Next Steps (Cm 8247) (January 2012)
Annex 2  R (Buckingham County Council 7 ors v Secretary of State for Transport 2013 EWHC 481 (Admin)
Annex 3  R (Buckingham County Council & ors v Secretary of State for Transport 2013 EWHC Civ 920
Annex 4(i)  R (HS2 Action Alliance) v Secretary of State for Transport 2014 UKSC 3
Annex 4(ii)  Statement of case of the First Communicant before the Supreme Court
Annex 4(iii)  Statement of Case for the Secretary of State for Transport before the Supreme Court
Annex 5  Third Witness Statement of Philip Graham dated 3 August 2012 (filed in the domestic proceedings) (redacted signature)
Annex 6  Witness Statement of Peter Miller (filed in the domestic proceedings) (redacted signature)
Annex 7  Witness Statement of Alison Munro (filed in the domestic proceedings) (redacted signature)
Annex 8  High Speed Two London to the West Midlands and Beyond A report by High Speed Two (HS2) Ltd
Annex 9  Command Paper - High Speed Rail (Cm 7827) (March 2010)
Annex 10  Appraisal of Sustainability A report for HS2 Ltd Non Technical Summary (Booz Temple) (December 2009)
Annex 11(i)  Atkins High Speed 2 Strategic Alternatives Study - Baseline report (2010)
Annex 11(ii)  Atkins High Speed 2 Strategic Alternatives Study - Highways interventions report (2010)
Annex 11(iii)  Atkins High Speed 2 Strategic Alternatives Study - Rail interventions report (2010)
Annex 11(iv)  Atkins High Speed 2 Strategic Alternatives Study - Strategic outline case (2010)
Annex 12  High Level Assessment of the wider network options - Reverse 'S' and 'Y' (HS2 Ltd October 2010)
Annex 13  High Speed Rail Investing in Britain's Future Consultation (February 2011)
Annex 14(i)  London to West Midlands Appraisal of Sustainability Volume 1 Main report
Annex 14(ii)  London to West Midlands Appraisal of Sustainability Volume 2 Plans and Appraisal Framework
Annex 14(iii)  London to West Midlands Appraisal of Sustainability Appendix 1 - the appraisal process
Annex 14(iv)  London to West Midlands Appraisal of Sustainability Appendix 2 - greenhouse gas emissions
Annex 14(v)  London to West Midlands Appraisal of Sustainability Appendix 3 - socio-economic report
Annex 14(vi)  London to West Midlands Appraisal of Sustainability Appendix 4 - assoicated assessment reports
Annex 14(vii)  London to West Midlands Appraisal of Sustainability Appendix 5 - technical reports
Annex 14(viii) London to West Midlands Appraisal of Sustainability Appendix 6 - March 2010 preferred scheme and main alternatives
Annex 14(ix)  London to West Midlands Appraisal of Sustainability - erratum
Annex 15  High Speed Strategic Alternatives Study London - West Midlands Rail Alternatives - Update of Economic Appraisal (February 2011)
Annex 16  High Speed Rail Investing in Britain's Future consultation summary (February 2011)
Annex 17  High Speed Rail Consultation Summary Report (November 2011) (Dialogue by Design
Annex 18  Review of the Government's Strategy for a National High Speed Rail Network (January 2012)
Annex 19  High Speed Rail Alternatives Study Update following consultation January 2012 (Atkins)
Annex 20  Review of Strategic Alternatives to High Speed Two November 2011 (Network Rail)
Annex 21  Review of possible refinements to the proposed HS2 London to West Midlands Route a report to Government by HS2 (January 2012)
Annex 22  Review of HS2 London to West Midlands Route Selection and Speed a report to Government by HS2 (January 2012)
Annex 23  Review of HS2 London to West Midlands Appraisal of Sustainability a report to Government by HS2 (January 2012)
Annex 24  High Speed Rail (London - West Midlands) Bill
Annex 25(i)  House of Commons Standing Order 27A
Annex 25(ii)  House of Commons Standing Order 224A
Annex 26  Draft EIA Scoping and Methodology Report on High Speed 2 (London to West Midlands)
Annex 27  Scoping and Methodology Consultlation summary report (Arup URS September 2012) (CT-001-000-3)
Annex 28  HS2 London to West Midlands EIA Scope and Methodology Report (Arup URS - September 2012) (CT-001-000-1)
Annex 29  HS2 draft environmental statement for London - West Midlands - a summary of consultation responses (2013)
Annex 30  London - West Midlands environmental statement Volume 5 Technical Appendices Alternatives Report
Annex 31(i)  HS2 London to West Midlands Environmental Statement Understanding the Environmental Statement
Annex 31(ii)  London - West Midlands Environmental Statement - Non- technical summary
Annex 31(iii)  London-West Midlands Environmental Statement Volume 1 Introduction to the Environmental Statement and Proposed Scheme
Annex 31(iv)   London - West Midlands Environmental Statement Volumne 2 Community Forum Area report - CFA 7 Colne Valley
Annex 31(v)  London - West Midlands Environmental Statement  Volume 2 Map books - CFA7 Colne Valley
Annex 31(vi)  London - West Midlands Environmental Statement Volume 3 Route-wide effects
Annex 31(vii)  London - West Midlands Environmental Statement Volume 4 Off-route effects
Annex 32  HS2 Independent Assessor report High Speed Rail (London - West Midlands) Bill summary of issues raised by comments on the environmental statement
Annex 33(i)  Minutes of oral evidence before the High Speed Rail Committee - 23 October 2014
Annex 33(ii)  Minutes of oral evidence before the High Speed Rail Committee - 20 November 2014 (front page and extract of paragraph 55)
Annex 34(i)  High Speed Rail (London - West Midlands) Bill Additional-Provision Amendment (September 2014)
Annex 34(ii)  High Speed Rail (London - West Midlands) Additional Provision Environmental Statement Non-technical summary (September 2014)
Annex 34(iii)  High Speed Rail (London - West Midlands Additional Provision Environmental Statement Volumess 1-3 and glossary (September 2014)
Annex 34(iv)  High Speed Rail (London - West Midlands) Additional Provision Environmental Statement Volume 2 Map books CFA07-CFA10 (September 2014)
Annex 34(v)  High Speed Rail (London - West Midlands) Additional Provision Environmental Statement Volume 5 map book environment topics (September 2014)
Annex 34(vi)  HS2 Independent Assessor High Speed Rail (London - West Midlands) Bill Additional Provision report (December 2014)
Annex 35  Environmental Audit Committee Report - HS2 and the environment
Annex 36  Environmental Audit Committee HS2 and the environment - Government response
Annex 37(i)  High Speed Rail Investing in Britain's Future consultation on the route from the West Midlands to Manchester, Leeds and beyond (July 2013)
Annex 37(ii)  HS Rail Consultation on the route from the West Midlands to Manchester, Leeds and beyond Vol 1 main report of appraisal of sustainability
Annex 38  High Speed 2 Information Paper A1 - Development of the HS2 Proposed Scheme
Annex 39(i)  Aston Cantlow and Wilmcote with Billesley Parochial Church Council v Wallbank and Another [2004] 1 A.C. 546
Annex 39(ii)  Stratford on Avon DC v Secretary of State for Communities and Local Government [2014] J.P.L. 104
Annex 39(iii)  R. (Greenpeace Ltd) v Secretary of State for Trade and Industry [2007] Env. L.R. 29
Annex 39(iv)  R (Westminster CC) v Mayor of London [2003] B.L.G.R. 611
Annex 39(v)  Wychavon CD v SSE [1994] Env LR 239
Annex 39(vi)  Encyclopedia of Local Government Law, vol. 2,  at paras. 3-12.25.3
Annex 40(i)  Islamic Republic of Iran Shipping Lines v Turkey (2008) 47 EHRR 24

From the Party concerned09.02.2015
Comments on the Party's responseFrom the communicant17.03.2015
Reply to the Committee's questions regarding status of second communicantFrom the communicants04.06.2015
Letter informing of the Committee's determination regarding London Borough of HillingdonFrom the secretariat07.08.2015
StatementFrom observer (Ms. Boman-Behram)29.08.2015
Email regarding scheduling of Committee's discussionFrom the Party concerned29.09.2015
Comments on Party concerned's request regarding scheduling of Committee's discussionFrom the communicants30.09.2015
Letter regarding scheduling of Committee's discussionFrom the Party concerned02.10.2015
Letter regarding scheduling of Committee's discussionFrom the communicants04.10.2015
Email to Parties regarding scheduling of Committee's discussionFrom the secretariat04.11.2015
Letters inviting Party concerned and communicants to hearing at Committee's 52nd meeting From the secretariat09.02.2016
Additional information
Annex A: Chronology
Annex B: List of Annexes
Annex 41: Respondent’s Statement of Case before the Supreme Court
Annex 42(i): ACCC/C/2006/16 (Lithuania): Addendum to the Compliance Committee Report, (ECE/MP.PP/2008/5/Add.6)
Annex 42(ii): Excerpt from the addendum to the report of the fifth session of the Meeting of the Parties (ECE/MP.PP/2014/Add.1)
Annex 42(iii): Extract from the second draft of the revised Guide to the Aarhus Convention Compliance Committee
Annex 43(i): De Wiles, Ooms and Versyp v Belgium [1971] ECHR 1
Annex 43(ii): The Interhandel Case (Switzerland v United States) [1959] I.C.J. Rep 6
Annex 44(i): R v North and East Devon Health Authority, Ex parte Coughlan [2001] QB 213
Annex 44(ii): Walton v Scottish Ministers [2012] UKSC 44
Annex 45: High Speed Rail Strategic Alternatives Study. Strategic Alternatives to the Proposed ‘Y’ Network (February 2011)
From the Party concerned25.02.2016
StatementFrom observer (Mr. Landells)04.03.2016 (dated 22.02.2016)
Opening statement for hearing at Committee's 52nd meetingFrom the Party concerned10.03.2016
Opening statement for hearing at Committee's 52nd meeting From the communicant10.03.2016
Joint statement for hearing at Committee's 52nd meeting From observers (Ms. Boman-Behram and Mr. Landells)10.03.2016
Letter to the parties enclosing questions from the CommitteeFrom the secretariat26.09.2016
StatementFrom observer (Ms. Rispin)21.10.2016

Reply to Committee's questions

Annex 1

Annex 2

Annex 3

Annex 4

From the communicant28.10.2016
Reply to Committee's questionsFrom the Party concerned31.10.2016
Comments on communicant's reply to Committee's questionsFrom the Party concerned11.11.2016
Comments on Party concerned's reply to Committee's questionsFrom the communicant11.11.2016

Statement

Annex 1: Speech at HS2 Select Committee of the House of Lords, 29.06.2016
Annex 2: Letter to Prime Minister, 05.09.2016

From observer (Ms. Boman-Behram)10.12.2016