Case status: Inadmissible.
Follow-up: -
Topics: Public participation; Access to justice.
Articles alleged: 6; 9 (2), 9 (3).
Articles considered by the Committee: -
Articles, if any, found in non-compliance: -
Summary: The communication was submitted to the Compliance Committee on 29 May 2018 by Mr. Artan Manushaqe, Mr. Andi Tepelena and Mr. Ervin Goci, three members of the public. The communication alleged a failure by the Party concerned to comply with articles 6, 9 (2) and (3) of the Convention in connection to the construction of a playground in a park in Tirana.
| Documents | Status | Date received or posted by the secretariat |
|---|---|---|
| Communication enclosing list of annexes Annex 1: Complaint’s authority form Annex 2: Council of Minister’s Decision No. 956 ENG ALB Annex 3: National Territory Council, Decision No. 4 ENG ALB Annex 4: Relevant domestic legislation ENG ALB Annex 5: Balkan Insight article Annex 6: Photos from the construction of the playground Annex 7: National Territory Council, decision 1 ENG ALB Annex 8: National Territory Council, building permit ENG ALB Annex 9: NGO letter ENG ALB Annex 10: Letter by National Environmental Agency ENG ALB Annex 11: Top Channel portal Annex 12: Excerpts from the playground's architectural designer's portfolio Annex 13: Architectural report ENG ALB Annex 14: Tirana Administrative Court decision of 12 May 2016 on interim measures ENG ALB Annex 15: Tirana Administrative Court decision of 11 July 2016 on merits (excerpts) ENG ALB Annex 16: Berfrois portal article |
From the communicant | 29.05.2018 |
| Additional information on domestic remedies Annex 1: Tirana Administrative Appeals Court decision no. 148/2018 ENG ALB Annex 2: Relevant domestic legislation ENG ALB Annex 3: Article on High Court Annex 4: Tirana Administrative Court decision 3782/2016 |
From the communicant | 29.04.2019 |
| Email update regarding domestic remedies Annex: ECHR case Keta v. Albania |
From the communicant | 29.05.2019 |
| Additional update regarding domestic remedies Annex 1: Commission report on Albania |
From the communicant | 04.06.2019 |
| Further update regarding domestic remedies Annex 1: Certificate of 3 October 2019 of pending appeal ENG ALB Annex 2: 2018 Annual Report of the High Judicial Council |
From the communicant | 04.10.2019 |
| Statement regarding admissibility | From the Party concerned | 04.11.2019 |
| Statement regarding admissibility including reply to Committee’s question on domestic remedies Annex 1: Relevant domestic law ENG ALB Annex 2: 2018 Annual Report of the High Judicial Council Annex 3: Keta v. Albania Annex 4: Bara v. Albania |
From the communicant | 04.11.2019 |
| Email notifying the parties of the Committee’s determination that communication is inadmissible | From the secretariat | 22.11.2019 |
| Letter with Committee’s reasoning as to admissibility | From the secretariat | 21.05.2020 |
| Request for a reconsideration of Committee’s determination of inadmissibility Annex 1 Annex 2 Annex 3 |
From the communicants | 24.06.2020 |
| Decision by Chair and Vice Chairs that the Committee’s determination of inadmissibility will stand | From the secretariat | 06.07.2020 |